Unwrapping the Enigma: The Best Christmas Mystery Movies

Welcome to the enchanting world of Christmas mystery movies, where holiday cheer meets suspenseful storytelling. As the festive season unfolds, what better way to celebrate than by delving into the captivating realms of cinematic enigma? In this blog post, we unwrap a curated selection of the best Christmas mystery movies that promise not only the warmth of the season but also the thrill of a good mystery.

As you snuggle up with a cup of hot cocoa and gather your loved ones around, these films will transport you to magical places, unravel intriguing plots, and leave you with a sense of wonder. From timeless classics to modern gems, each movie on our list brings a unique blend of holiday spirit and mystery. So, join us as we explore the joy of Christmas through the lens of suspense, laughter, and heartwarming tales.

Let the holiday festivities begin with a touch of mystery that will keep you guessing and leave you with a heart full of Christmas magic.

The Polar Express (2004)

Overview

“The Polar Express” takes us on a magical journey aboard a mysterious train heading to the North Pole on Christmas Eve. Tom Hanks stars in this animated masterpiece directed by Robert Zemeckis.

Plot Synopsis

As the story unfolds, a young boy embarks on an extraordinary adventure, encountering peculiar characters and overcoming challenges. The mystery deepens as the true spirit of Christmas is revealed. This is one of my favourite Christmas mystery movies and I would love to hear your thoughts below.

Interesting Fact

Did you know that “The Polar Express” is based on the beloved children’s book of the same name by Chris Van Allsburg? The film beautifully captures the enchanting illustrations and brings them to life.

Where Can I Watch The Polar Express?

Presently, you have the opportunity to indulge in the enchanting journey of “The Polar Express” through streaming services such as Sky Go and Now TV Cinema. For those who prefer to own their digital copy, the movie is available for purchase on various platforms, including Apple TV, Amazon Video, Sky Store, Microsoft Store, Rakuten TV, and Google Play Movies. Additionally, if you’re inclined to rent the film for a delightful one-time viewing, options abound on Apple TV, Amazon Video, Google Play Movies, Sky Store, Microsoft Store, YouTube, and Rakuten TV. This extensive availability ensures that the magic of “The Polar Express” is just a click away, providing flexibility for audiences to enjoy this timeless holiday classic on their preferred platforms.

The Bishop’s Wife (1947)

Overview

A classic black-and-white gem, “The Bishop’s Wife” is a heartwarming yet mysterious tale directed by Henry Koster. Cary Grant, Loretta Young, and David Niven deliver memorable performances.

Plot Synopsis

The story revolves around an angel named Dudley, played by Cary Grant, who visits a troubled bishop during the holiday season. As Dudley works his miracles, the true mystery lies in the transformative power of love and faith.

Interesting Fact

Originally, the film was intended to be a straight drama, but it evolved into a delightful blend of romance and fantasy, making it a unique entry in the Christmas mystery movies genre.

Where Can I Watch The Bishop’s Wife?

At present, you have the opportunity to experience the heartwarming charm of “The Bishop’s Wife” via streaming on Amazon Prime Video. Alternatively, for those who wish to have a permanent digital copy, the movie is available for purchase on Amazon Video. If you’re leaning towards a one-time viewing, renting “The Bishop’s Wife” is also an option through Amazon Video’s online rental services. This diverse accessibility ensures that the captivating tale of this classic film is easily within reach, allowing viewers to engage with the narrative on their terms, be it through streaming or ownership.

If you have access to BBC iPlayer, you can watch it for free on there too.

Home Alone (1990)

Overview

While primarily known as a comedy, “Home Alone” directed by Chris Columbus has elements of mystery and suspense. Macaulay Culkin stars as Kevin McCallister, a young boy accidentally left behind during the holidays.

Plot Synopsis

As Kevin defends his home from burglars using inventive traps, the mystery lies in whether he can outsmart the intruders before his family returns. The film’s humor, combined with unexpected twists, makes it a timeless Christmas classic. Do you think it belongs in the Christmas mystery movies list?

Interesting Fact

“Home Alone” was a massive box office success and held the record as the highest-grossing live-action comedy film until 2011. Its popularity endures as a holiday favorite for audiences of all ages.

Where Can I Watch Home Alone?

Presently, the timeless holiday hilarity of “Home Alone” is available for streaming on Disney Plus, providing a convenient platform for those eager to revel in the mischievous adventures of Kevin McCallister. Additionally, for enthusiasts who wish to secure a permanent digital copy of the film, “Home Alone” is up for purchase on various platforms including Apple TV, Amazon Video, Google Play Movies, Sky Store, Microsoft Store, YouTube, and Rakuten TV. For those who prefer a one-time viewing experience, the option to rent “Home Alone” is accessible through Amazon Video, Rakuten TV, Apple TV, Google Play Movies, Sky Store, Microsoft Store, and YouTube, making it effortless for viewers to choose their preferred method of enjoying this holiday classic.

The Thin Man (1934)

Overview

Set against the backdrop of the holiday season, “The Thin Man” is a stylish and witty Christmas mystery directed by W.S. Van Dyke. William Powell and Myrna Loy star as the sophisticated detective duo, Nick and Nora Charles.

Plot Synopsis

Nick and Nora Charles find themselves entangled in a murder mystery during a Christmas gathering. With sharp dialogue and a delightful mix of comedy and suspense, the film has become a classic in the detective genre.

Interesting Fact

“The Thin Man” spawned a successful film series, and Nick and Nora Charles became iconic characters. The film’s popularity led to a cultural impact, influencing the portrayal of detectives in subsequent movies and television shows.

Where Can I Watch The Thin Man?

The captivating detective tale of “The Thin Man” can be experienced through streaming options by either renting or purchasing on prominent platforms such as Vudu, Google Play, and Amazon. Whether you opt for the flexibility of renting or desire to own a digital copy, these platforms offer the opportunity to immerse yourself in the sophisticated and witty world of Nick and Nora Charles, ensuring that the intrigue of “The Thin Man” is readily accessible to a diverse audience.

Elf (2003)

Overview

“Elf” directed by Jon Favreau is a Christmas mystery wrapped in comedy and fantasy. Will Ferrell stars as Buddy, a human raised by elves who embarks on a journey to discover his true identity.

Plot Synopsis

While the main focus is on Buddy’s hilarious fish-out-of-water experiences, the mystery lies in the heartwarming exploration of family and self-discovery. The film is a perfect blend of laughter and holiday spirit. The question is do you think Elf should be on this Christmas mystery movies list or not? Let us know below.

Interesting Fact

“Elf” has gained a cult following and has become a modern holiday classic. Its success can be attributed to Will Ferrell’s endearing performance and the film’s ability to balance humor with a meaningful message.

Where Can I Watch Elf?

Presently, the heartwarming holiday hilarity of “Elf” is available for streaming on Sky Go and Now TV Cinema, offering a delightful viewing experience for those in search of festive laughter. For those who wish to have a lasting digital copy, “Elf” is purchasable on various platforms, including Sky Store, Apple TV, Amazon Video, Microsoft Store, Rakuten TV, Google Play Movies, and YouTube. Alternatively, if you’re leaning towards a one-time viewing, the option to rent “Elf” is accessible on Apple TV, Amazon Video, Google Play Movies, Sky Store, Microsoft Store, YouTube, and Rakuten TV, providing a multitude of choices for viewers to enjoy this modern holiday classic at their convenience.

Why Christmas Mystery Movies?

As the credits roll and the final scenes fade, these Christmas mystery movies leave behind more than just entertainment—they gift you with a festive experience that lingers in your heart. Whether you’re a fan of heartwarming tales, classic whodunits, or comedic adventures, this curated list offers something for everyone.

So, why should you watch these movies? Because beyond the twinkling lights, joyful carols, and festive decorations, these films capture the essence of Christmas in a unique way. They invite you to believe in miracles, cherish loved ones, and embrace the spirit of giving. In the midst of holiday chaos, these Christmas mystery movies provide a perfect escape, allowing you to lose yourself in stories that blend the magic of the season with the allure of the unknown.

This holiday season, let these films be your companions, adding an extra layer of excitement and joy to your celebrations. Gather your loved ones, dim the lights, and let the mysteries unfold, creating cherished memories that will last long after the decorations are packed away. Wishing you a Merry Christmas filled with wonder, laughter, and the magic of the movies.

Do you have any favourite Christmas mystery movies? Have we missed any off? Let me know any Christmas mystery movies that you think should be on this list and I will try to add them.

Christmas Movie Club

If you are in the mood for some other types of Christmas movies to watch, then click on the image below to go to our Christmas movie page.